11 Alternative Flavored Coffees to Pumpkin Spice

It’s Pumpkin Spice Season! Whether this fact elicits a cheer or a groan, it’s now a part of our Autumn framework. There are those who are super excited when PSL (that’s Pumpkin Spice Latte to those new to this phenomenon) season hits and those who just wish it would go away. Regardless of which way you lean, we’ve got your bases covered.

autumn coffee

What if you want to change things up for Fall but don’t know what to try, you just know you don’t want Pumpkin Spice? Let’s take a look at your options!

But I Want Pumpkin Spice!

Okay, let’s just get Pumpkin Spice out of the way. Those of you who love it and can’t get enough, we do understand. Here is our Pumpkin Spice post from a couple of years ago. With flavored coffee, syrups, recipes, and even teas, there are some great choices!

What Else Is There?

Now, for those of you who want something Fall-inspired but don’t want Pumpkin Spice, Here are a few flavored coffee alternatives.

Salted Caramel

Sweet, gooey caramel. Now that can take you back. Add a modern twist with a sprinkle of sea salt and you have a slightly more adult version. Our Salted Caramel Flavored coffee is a delightful option for the Fall. 

Vermont Maple Pecan

Nothing brings Autumn to mind better than Vermont. Just imagining the crisp air and the cacophony of colors in the Vermont mountains is enough to get anyone into the spirit of Fall. Try our Vermont Maple Pecan Flavored coffee with flavors of sweet Vermont maple syrup and buttery Georgia pecans blended with our 100% arabica bean coffee. Is it sweater weather yet?

Autumn Harvest Spice

Okay, this is pretty close to Pumpkin Spice, but it focuses more on the spices than on the pumpkin. With strong flavors of cinnamon and nutmeg and just a hint of pumpkin, our Autumn Harvest Spice Flavored coffee might be the ideal choice for those who like the idea of the PSL but are tired of the P portion of it. 

Blackberry Cobbler

How about something a little more on the fruity side of things. Our Blackberry Cobbler Flavored coffee is a mouthwatering choice that takes the flavor of juicy, ripe blackberries and blends it with flavors of buttery, crusty pastry. Like grandma used to make for the holidays, you’ll love this delectable mix of pie and coffee all in one.

Caramel Apple

Crispy, juicy Fall harvested apples dipped in gooey, buttery caramel… nothing says Fall in quite the same way. Our Caramel Apple Flavored coffee will bring back the days of trick-or-treating when that homemade treat was the best thing in your bag.

Toasted Praline

Sweet brown sugar, rich milk, creamy butter, and toasted pecans all come together gloriously to make delectable toasted pralines. Our Toasted Praline Flavored coffee blends these flavors with our pure arabica bean coffee for a treat within a treat. A sweet way to spend a chilly Autumn afternoon.

Creme Brulee

Custardy deliciousness blended perfectly with pure gourmet coffee. Our Creme Brulee Flavored coffee will delight your taste buds with the unmistakable flavor of this rich and creamy classic dessert.

Cinnamon Sweet Potato Swirl

The classic holiday side dish meets our pure arabica bean coffee in our Cinnamon Sweet Potato Swirl Flavored coffee. Yummy sweet potatoes blended with rich butter, sweet brown sugar, and a dash of cinnamon are a delightful companion to freshly roasted coffee. This might be your new fall obsession.

Southern Pecan

Looking for something a little less sweet? Our Southern Pecan Flavored coffee might just be your thing. The flavor of toasted Georgia pecans is a savory, buttery treat when added to our freshly roasted coffee beans. Give your sweet tooth a break with this delicious coffee.

Peach Cobbler

Here in the Peach State, we take our peach cobbler seriously. You know our Peach Cobbler Flavored coffee is going to taste like the real deal. Juicy, ripe peaches and a flaky, buttery pastry crust… you won’t be able to get enough of this Southern favorite.

How About Something Super Unique?

Alright. We’ve got you. How about our Maple Bacon® Flavored coffee? Yep! Crispy farmhouse bacon drenched in sweet Vermont maple blended with pure, 100% arabica bean coffee right in your cup. This might just have you hopping out of bed on those chilly Fall mornings. (But you can also totally have a cup in bed!)

We hope these alternatives to Pumpkin Spice will help you get in the right mood this Fall season. Let us know your favorite!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *